This electronic document is provided by The Eisenhower National Clearinghouse for Mathematics and Science Education. For more information regarding The Eisenhower National Clearinghouse (ENC), go to ENC's home page.
Recent literature concerning the role of school library media programs in the "information age" reverberates with several themes: information literacy, lifelong learning, critical thinking, and resource-based learning. These themes emphasize the changing role of the school library media specialist-one that is characterized as an instructional partnership between teachers and the school library media specialist. The call for a more proactive role in the instructional process is not new, however. Direct and active involvement in the school's instructional program has been widely advocated in the professional literature of the field for several decades. In 1988, instructional consultation was firmly established as one of the three essential roles of the school library media specialist in Information Power.[1] Today, however, the rapid expansion of technologies for information and instruction, together with the movement toward school restructuring, add a new urgency to the role of the school library media specialist. The information-rich era demands that the profession move beyond the traditional library functions to encompass a broader range of responsibilities in the learning process. It is well past the time to embrace the "second revolution" envisioned by David Loertscher more than a decade ago.[2]
Simply put, functioning as an instructional consultant, the school library media specialist forms planning partnerships with teachers.
Though the instructional consultation role has been widely espoused, there remains a gap between the theory and its practice. Studies have consistently reached the same conclusion: with few exceptions, school library media specialists are not involved in instructional planning. As recently as 1991, for example, Miller and Shontz[5] found that while school library media specialists at all levels reported participating in informal, spur-of-the-moment planning, there was little involvement in formal planning with teachers. They concluded that library media specialists "have not yet adjusted their concept of integration of library resources into the curriculum to include the need for formal planning with teacher colleagues."[6]
Why have school library media specialists and teachers failed to plan collaboratively? What's keeping school library media specialists from direct and active involvement in the instructional process? Blame can be found in the attitudes and perceptions held among teachers, administrators, and school library media specialists themselves. For example, Kerr[7] found school library media specialists to be disinterested in instructional consultation at the same time that teachers were indifferent, if not resistant, to having them involved. Hodges[8] reported that teachers and administrators do not consider an active role in curriculum and instructional planning an appropriate one for the school library media specialist. Other factors that interfere with fulfilling an instructional consultation function include lack of time, training, and administrative support.[9]
Perhaps there is another, more fundamental reason why instructional consultation has yet to reach fruition. It is more than likely that neither school library media specialists nor teachers understand the nature of instructional planning. Planning instruction is an activity in which all teachers engage but few may articulate or reflect upon. The nature of how teachers think about and go about planning instruction may be as unfamiliar to school library media specialists as it is to teachers themselves. Even those who advocate that school library media specialists become more involved in instructional consulting may not fully understand the nature of instructional planning as practiced by classroom teachers. The purpose of this article is to provide school library media specialists with an understanding of how teachers plan instruction. The article describes the phenomenon known as teacher planning, summarizes related research, and suggests strategies for incorporating research on teacher planning into the practice of instructional consulting. Understanding the process by which teachers approach and structure instruction is central to working in partnership with teachers.
The latter definition of planning represents the aspect of professional practice that Schon refers to as "knowing-inaction . . . the characteristic mode of ordinary practical knowledge."[12] He explains the implicit nature of this knowledge that underlies our actions in both our personal and professional lives:
Similarly, the workaday life of the professional depends on tacit knowing-in-action. Every competent practitioner can recognize phenomena. .. for which he cannot give a reasonably accurate or complete description. In his day-today practice, he makes innumerable judgments of quality for which he cannot state rules and procedures. Even when he makes conscious use of research-based theories and techniques, he is dependent on tacit recognitions, judgments and skillful performances.[13]
The study of teacher planning is a relatively recent focus of research. As part of the larger body of research concerned with teachers' thought processes, research on teacher planning has focused on that of experienced elementary teachers. Research on teacher planning is concerned with teachers' preactive and postactive thoughts i.e., those thoughts about teaching occurring prior to and following interaction with students, respectively. The growing body of teacher planning research is beginning to paint a picture of how teachers plan. The following summarizes some of the major findings.
Planning is influenced by published curriculum materials. Clark and Elmore,[36] and Smith and Sendelbach[37] found that teachers depend heavily on published curriculum and teachers' guides for content and methods. Oberg[38] reports that teachers plan around materials they have on hand.
Occasions for conversations about teaching can be formal or informal. Arrange a meeting to talk specifically about planning instructional units and activities, but also take advantage of less formal, spur-of-the-moment opportunities that present themselves. For example, when a teacher asks for materials depicting colonial living, the library media specialist can take the time to discover the nature of the activity, including its purpose and relationship to broader curriculum objectives.
In the course of reflecting, be open to new ways of looking at teaching and help teachers to do likewise. Address the full range of issues that constitute the planning task. Encourage teachers to share their wealth of knowledge about students, content, and methods. With them, explore their goals, and move them to discussions of objectives and evaluation.
Collaborative reflection should reveal the teachers' planning style, the important elements that they consider when planning, and the type of planning in which they engage. Together, teacher and library media specialist can articulate the implicit planning routines and mental images that underlie their actions. Through discussion, both teacher and library media specialist gain a mutual understanding of their interrelated roles.
Planning models such as Turner's perpetuate the misconception that a linear, means-end design process is appropriate for instructional consulting with classroom teachers. Planning, as prescribed in numerous instructional design models, is not the same as teacher planning. While the design models may be prescriptive for effective instruction created by instructional designers, they are not descriptive of how classroom teachers approach the process of planning instruction. Teachers have a different perspective.
In light of recent research, those providing instructional consultation would be well advised to set aside linear planning models in favor of an approach that is more reflective of teachers' planning processes. Although there is as yet no definitive model of teacher planning, the following conceptualization, which is research-based, may prove useful as a working model.
Think of planning as a series of increasingly broader-reaching concentric circles radiating out from the central focus-typically the instructional task. Much like the effect of a pebble tossed into a pond, elements such as the dimensions of the content, the characteristics of the students, and the dynamics of the social and cultural enviromment are encompassed as the circles move outward. In this fashion, the elements identified as essential to effective instruction are taken into account, but in a process that is recursive and successively elaborate. With a wavelike or rippling action, the consideration of one element affects all the others.
Regardless of the starting point, the library media specialist's role as an instructional consultant is to see that the important elements are considered with respect to the instructional task. Sequence is a minor concern provided that the elements are considered in terms of the whole and revisited with respect to their interaction with one another.
In the tradition of an instructional designer, the library media specialist may find it important to produce written records of planning, but may be frustrated by teachers who do not. If making planning concrete by committing ideas to paper is important, keep documentation simple and to a minimum. Remember that elaborate task analyses and copious lesson plans can be frustrating to classroom teachers whose planning is captured in mental images.
Unit planning is made to order for teacher and school library media specialist planning. This typical type of planning begs for collaboration and is an entree to whole-language and resource-based learning. For example, if a fourth-grade teacher wants to do a unit on Native American foods in connection with Thanksgiving, begin by providing appropriate materials, then suggest a variety of learning activities, especially those that would involve the use of the library media center facilities and its resources. Also take this opportunity to integrate instructional goals related to the development of information literacy skills into the instruction.
Identify both comprehensive and incremental planners among the faculty. Thoroughly plan units of instruction with the comprehensive planners; help them to work out the details and lay out the "big picture." Support incremental planners by accommodating their less detailed and more immediate planning. Encourage experimentation with techniques and materials; debrief and plan revised lessons with them. Customize planning to fit the teacher. Create models based on the approaches of individual teachers. There may be a number of models-as many as there are teachers.
Use curriculum and teachers' guides as a springboard to greater involvement in planning. Teachers may rely on curriculum guides not from a lack of creativity, but from a lack of time or familiarity with available resources. Capitalize on this aspect of the library media specialist's role, one with which teachers are most familiar and accepting. As the information specialist, provide them with the best resources; expose the treasures of the collection and the world of resources beyond it. Pull together a wide variety of media and offer suggestions for their use and integration.
Living up to the challenge requires that library media professionals realize the full dimension of their role: information specialist, teacher, and instructional consultant. Library media specialists must assume a more proactive and involved role in planning curriculum and instruction; they must work in partnership with teachers. A successful instructional partnership hinges on the library media specialist's understanding of the planning process as teachers see and practice it. Collaborative planning is the library media specialist's survival skill-a skill that becomes even more important as the concepts of information literacy, lifelong learning, and resource-based learning propel us into a third revolution.
2. David V. Loertscher, "The Second Revolution: A Taxonomy for the 1980s:' Wilson Library Bulletin (Feb. 1982): 417-21 . (Click here to return)
3. Philip M. Turner and Stephen W. Zsiray, Jr.., :The Consulting Role of the School Library Media Specialist," in The Research of School Library Media Centers, ed. Blanche Woolls (Castle Rock, Colo.: High Willow Research and Publishing, 1990), 1-20. (Click here to return)
4. AASL and Association for Educational Communications and Technology, Information Power, 35. (Click here to return)
5. Marilyn L. Miller and Marilyn Shontz, "Expenditures for Resources in School Library Media Centers, FY '89-90," School Library Journal 37 (Aug. 1991): 32-42. (Click here to return)
6. Ibid.,41. (Click here to return)
7. Stephen T. Kerr, "Are There Instructional Developers in the Schools?" AV Communication Review 25 (Fall 1977): 24368. (Click here to return)
8. Gerald C. Hodges, "The Instructional Role of the School Library Media Specialist: What Research Says to Us," School Media Quarterly 9 (Summer 1981): 281-85. (Click here to return)
9. Philip M. Turner, "Information Skills and Instructional Consulting: A Synergy," School Library Media Quarterly 20 (Fall 1991): 13-18. (Click here to return)
10. Christopher M. Clark and Penelope L. Peterson, "Teachers' Thought Processes:' in Handbook of Research on Teaching, 3d ed., ed. Merlin C. Wittrock (New York: Macmillan, 1986), 255-96. (Click here to return)
11. Ibid., 260.(Click here to return)
12. Donald Schon, The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action (New York: Basic Books, 1983). (Click here to return)
13. Ibid., 49-50.(Click here to return)
14. Christopher M. Clark and Robert J. Yinger, Three Studies of Teacher Planning. Research Series no. 55 (East Lansing: Michigan State Univ., Institute for Research on Teaching, 1979). (Click here to return)
15. Gail McCutcheon, "How Do Elementary Teachers Plan? The Nature of Planning and Influences on It," Elementary School Journal 81 (Sept. 1980): 4-23. (Click here to return)
16. Clark and Yinger, Three Studies.(Click here to return)
17. McCutcheon, "How Do Elementary Teachers Plan?" (Click here to return)
18. Greta Morine-Dershimer, "What's in a Plan? Stated and Unstated Plans for Lessons." A paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New York, April 1977.(Click here to return)
19. Ibid. (Click here to return)
20. Greta Morine-Dershimer, Teacher Plan and Classroom Reality: The South Bay Study: Part 4, Research Series no. 60. (East Lansing: Michigan State Univ., Institute for Research on Teaching, 1979).(Click here to return)
21. E. L. Smith and N. B. Sendelbach, "Teacher Intentions for Science Instruction and Their Antecedents in Program Materials." A paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, April 1979. (Click here to return)
22. Robert 1. Yinger, A Study of Teacher Planning: Description and Theory Development Using Ethnographic and Information Processing Methods (Ph.D.. diss., Michigan State Univ., 1977). (Click here to return)
23. Ralph W. Tyler, Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction (Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Pr., 1949). (Click here to return)
24. Robert J. Yinger, "Routines in Teacher Planning," Theory into Practice 18 (June 1979): 163-69. (Click here to return)
25. Penelope L. Peterson, Ronald W. Marx, and Christopher M. Clark, 'Teacher Planning, Teacher Behavior, and Student Achievement " American Educational Research Journal 15 (Summer 19;8): 417-32. (Click here to return)
26. P. H. Taylor, How Teachers Plan Their Courses: Studies in Curriculum Planning (Slough, Berkshire, England: National Foundation for Educational Research in England and Wales, 1970). (Click here to return)
27. John A. Zahorik, "Teachers' Planning Models," Educational Leadership 33 (Nov. 1975): 134-39.(Click here to return)
28. Greta Morine-Dershimer and Elizabeth Vallance, Teacher Planning. Beginning Teacher Evaluation Study Special Report C (San Francisco: Far West Laboratory for Educational Research and Development, 1976). (Click here to return)
29. Taylor, How Teachers Plan. (Click here to return)
30. Morine-Dershimer and Vallance, Teacher Planning. (Click here to return)
31. Peterson Marx, and Clark "Teacher Planning." (Click here to return)
32. Zahorik, 'Teachers' Planning."(Click here to return)
33. Richard Shavelson, "Planning," in The International Encyclopedia of Teaching and Teacher Education, ed. Michael 1. Dunkin (Oxford: Pergamon, 1987), 483-86.(Click here to return)
34. Taylor, How Teachers Plan. (Click here to return)
35. Christopher M. Clark and Janis M. Elmore, Teacher Planning in the First Weeks of School, Research Series no. 56 (East Lansing: Michigan State Univ., Institute for Research on Teaching, 1979). (Click here to return)
36. Ibid. (Click here to return)
37. Smith and Sendelbach, "Teacher Intentions." (Click here to return)
38. Antoinette Oberg, "The School Librarian and the Classroom Teacher Partners in Curriculum Planning ' Emergency Librarian 14 (Sept./Oct. 1986): 9-14. (Click here to return)
39. Philip M. Turner, Helping Teachers Teach (Littleton, Colo.: Libraries Unlimited,1985). (Click here to return)
40. Ibid., 15. (Click here to return)
41. Christopher M. Clark and Magdalene Lambert, "The Study of Teacher Thinking: Implications for Teacher Education," Journal of Teacher Education 37 (Sept./Oct. 1986): 27-31.(Click here to return)
42. Loertscher, 'The Second Revolution." (Click here to return)
43. Carol-Ann Haycock, "Developing the School Resource Centre Program: A Systematic Approach," Emergency Librarian 12 (Sept./Oct. 1984): 9-16. (Click here to return)
44. Loertscher, "The Second Revolution," 421. (Click here to return)